Water Help / Your options
Water softener or scale conditioner?
Both deal with scale, but they work differently. A softener removes the minerals. A conditioner leaves them in the water and aims to stop them sticking.
| Salt-based softener | Scale conditioner (ring) | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Swaps calcium and magnesium for sodium (ion exchange) | Fitted around the pipe; minerals stay in the water |
| Water hardness | Reduced | Unchanged; the aim is less scale |
| Running needs | Salt top-ups, regeneration water, servicing | No power, salt or servicing |
| Installation | Plumbed in, needs space and a drain | Clamped on in about 15 minutes |
| Things to know | Adds sodium to the water; regeneration wastes some water | Results vary from site to site, so test before and after |
Which suits you?
If you need water that is measurably soft, for example for some industrial processes, a softener is the direct route. If your concern is scale on pipes, elements and taps and you want nothing to maintain, a conditioner is worth considering, as long as you measure the result.
Whatever you choose, test your water before installation and again a few months later, and photograph the same kettle, showerhead or element. That's how you'll know it's working.
Want someone to look at your water?
A local installer can check your setup and give you a quote.